Revisiting Chianti Classico - Results, March 2012

This past Tuesday, March 20th, 2012, the Toronto Vintners Club presented the rare opportunity, to go back and re-visit our tasting from back in March of 2010.  It was a unique opportunity to revisit these wines and to see what effect 2 additional years of cellaring had on these wines.  Our Guest returning gust speaker for the evening was Julian Hitner, who last joined Toronto Vintners Club for our Brunello di Montalcino tasting in Feb. 2011.

Over all, pretty much everyone was in agreement on their wine rankings, with the older of the wines tasted coming out on top.  Julian ranked the 2005 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico as his top wine of the evening, saying that it had great notes of salami and roasted meat with also just a very faint port like element hiding in the background.  This wine had firm tannins that were balanced with perfect acidity.  The group's top pick was the same wine, but the older of the two vintages present that night, the 2003 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico.  According to Julian, this wine was very refined and had a great red cherry/garnet colour.  It was a very complex wine, with notes of pipe tobacco, roasted meats and cigar boxes.

Here are how the wines were ranked:

Name of Wine (in order poured)	Group Ranking	Guest Ranking
A - 2007 Badia a Coltibuono Chianti Classico $35	8	8
B - 2007 Isole E Olena Chianti Classico $35	3	7
C - 2006 Isole E Olena Chianti Classico $36	7	4
D - 2006 Badia a Coltibuono Chianti Classico Reserva $62	6	5
E - 2006 Antinori Peppoli Chianti Classico $23	2	6
F - 2005 Antinori Badia A Passignano Riserva $51	5	3
G - 2005 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico $45	4	1
H - 2003 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico $55	1	2

Comparing this years tasting to that of 2010, we can see that there has been quite a bit of movement of the wine that are in the middle of the pack.  The biggest jump in rankings was the for the 2006 Antinori Peppoli Chianti Classico, which moved from 5th place overall to second.


Here are how we ranked the wines in 2010:

Name of Wine (in order poured)	Group Ranking	Guest Ranking
A - 2007 Badia a Coltibuono Chianti Classico $35	8	7
B - 2007 Isole E Olena Chianti Classico $35	4	3
C - 2006 Isole E Olena Chianti Classico $36	7	6
D - 2006 Badia a Coltibuono Chianti Classico Reserva $62	3	5
E - 2006 Antinori Peppoli Chianti Classico $23	5	8
F - 2005 Antinori Badia A Passignano Riserva $51	1	2
G - 2005 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico $45	6	4
H - 2003 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico $55	2	1